Landscape image showcasing a modern digital marketing theme with rooftops, bar charts, and customer review icons like stars and speech bubbles, symbolizing trust, professionalism, and online reputation in the roofing industry.

Number of Reviews Impacts CPA & Market Share for Roofers

January 17, 20253 min read

Introduction: Why Online Reviews Matter

In today’s digital-first economy, online reviews are a critical asset for roofing companies looking to expand their market share and reduce their cost-per-acquisition (CPA). Reviews shape consumer trust, influence purchasing decisions, and directly impact marketing efficiency. For regional roofing businesses, the relationship between reviews and market growth is even more pronounced. This page explores how leveraging online reviews can boost visibility, build trust, and drive profitability for roofing companies.

The Correlation Between Reviews and Market Share

Pyramid of Market Share vs. Review Percentage

The relationship between the number of reviews and market share can be visualized through the following structure:

  1. 1,000+ Reviews: Dominating the local market with approximately 35% market share.

  2. 500-999 Reviews: Establishing a strong online presence with around 20% market share.

  3. 250-499 Reviews: Representing growing reputation, holding approximately 10% market share.

  4. 100-249 Reviews: Securing a foothold in the market with roughly 5% market share.

  5. 50-99 Reviews: Emerging players with around 2% market share.

  6. 21-49 Reviews: Smaller companies holding less than 1% market share.

  7. 5-20 Reviews: Limited visibility and market access.

Key Insight: Companies with higher review volumes consistently capture larger portions of the market. This highlights the importance of actively managing and increasing review counts to outperform competitors.

Professional marketing team collaborating with a roofing company in a modern office setting, featuring detailed charts, graphs, and roofing materials to emphasize strategies for improving online reviews, market share, and CPA in the roofing industry.

Reviews and Cost-Per-Acquisition (CPA)

Cost Efficiency Through Reviews

Higher review counts not only enhance market share but also reduce marketing costs. As the number of reviews increases:

  • 5-24 Reviews: CPA can exceed $900.

  • 25-49 Reviews: CPA reduces to approximately $700.

  • 50-99 Reviews: CPA drops to $600.

  • 100-249 Reviews: CPA decreases further to $450.

  • 250-499 Reviews: CPA approaches $300.

  • 500-999 Reviews: CPA stabilizes around $200.

  • 1,000+ Reviews: CPA reaches its most efficient level, often below $150.

Why This Happens: Positive reviews build trust and reduce customer hesitation, making acquisition more cost-effective.

How Ad Networks Evaluate Business Reputation

The Role of Reviews in Digital Advertising

Ad networks like Google and Facebook rely heavily on business reputation signals to determine ad performance and rankings. Here’s how reviews influence these platforms:

  1. Review Volume: Higher counts indicate credibility and consistent customer engagement.

  2. Review Quality: Positive sentiment and authenticity are weighted heavily.

  3. Review Diversity: A mix of recent and older reviews across multiple platforms enhances reputation scoring.

  4. Reputation Scoring Algorithms: Advanced systems evaluate patterns to detect manipulated reviews and reward genuine performance.

Pro Tip: Roofing companies should prioritize collecting reviews on platforms like Google Business Profile and Yelp to improve their ad performance.

Strategies to Optimize Online Reviews

1. Proactively Request Reviews

  • Ask Satisfied Customers: Politely request reviews after completing a project.

  • Automate Requests: Use CRM tools to send automated follow-up emails or texts.

2. Focus on Customer Experience

  • Exceed Expectations: Deliver high-quality service to encourage positive feedback.

  • Respond Promptly: Address issues to turn negative experiences into positive resolutions.

3. Diversify Review Platforms

  • Google My Business: Essential for local SEO and visibility.

  • Industry-Specific Sites: Platforms like Angi or HomeAdvisor cater to roofing clients.

  • Social Media: Encourage reviews on Facebook and Instagram.

4. Monitor and Analyze Feedback

  • Track Trends: Use review management tools to identify recurring themes.

  • Respond Publicly: Show appreciation for positive reviews and professionalism in addressing criticism.

Modern suburban neighborhood with detailed residential rooftops, overlaid with digital marketing elements like star ratings, thumbs-up icons, and bar charts, symbolizing customer reviews and performance metrics for lead generation in the roofing industry.

Case Study: The ROI of Reviews

A roofing company in Central Indiana with 1,000+ reviews achieved:

  • 35% Market Share: Dominating the local industry.

  • CPA Reduction: Lowered acquisition costs by 60% compared to competitors with fewer reviews.

  • Increased Conversions: Positive reviews led to higher lead-to-customer conversion rates.

This demonstrates the tangible benefits of investing in review management.

Key Takeaways

  1. Boost Visibility: Online reviews improve search rankings and attract more leads.

  2. Build Trust: A strong review profile fosters credibility and long-term relationships.

  3. Drive Profitability: Higher reviews correlate with reduced CPA and increased revenue.

Next Steps: Roofing companies should implement review generation and management strategies to scale their business and stay competitive.

Ready to Scale Your Roofing Business?

Contact us to learn how to enhance your online reputation and dominate your local market.

Email: [email protected]
Phone: (602) 571-2491
Website: https://www.mostdope.com/

Take control of your reviews and watch your business grow!

PDF Presentation: https://issuu.com/mostdope/docs/impact

With over 27 years experience in online marketing with an emphasis on roofing and home improvement, Matt is passionate about scaling businesses through lead generation.

Matt

With over 27 years experience in online marketing with an emphasis on roofing and home improvement, Matt is passionate about scaling businesses through lead generation.

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog